Counts and Percents

Reasons Federal Prosecutors Decline to Prosecute Civil Rights Cases

  Number Percent
Fiscal Year
96
Total 3,044 100.0
disposition reason 96 3.2
Agency request
Civil, admin or other disciplinary alternatives 35 1.1
Declined per instructions from DOJ 453 14.9
Department Policy 4 0.1
Jurisdiction or venue problems 5 0.2
Juvenile suspect 1 0.0
Lack of evidence of criminal intent 348 11.4
Lack of investigative or prosecutive resources 27 0.9
Lack of investigative resources 2 0.1
Lack of prosecutive resources 7 0.2
Minimal federal interest or no deterrent value 85 2.8
No federal offense evident 371 12.2
No known suspect 72 2.4
Offender's age, health, prior record, or personal matter 5 0.2
Office policy 11 0.4
Pretrial Diversion Completed 1 0.0
Rule 40 1 0.0
Staleness 13 0.4
Statute of Limitations 121 4.0
Suspect being prosecuted on other charges (e.g., UFAPs) 20 0.7
Suspect deceased 3 0.1
Suspect serving sentence 1 0.0
Suspect to be prosecuted by other authorities 101 3.3
Suspect's cooperation 1 0.0
Transfer within District 4 0.1
Weak or insufficient admissible evidence 1,195 39.3
Witness problems 61 2.0

Data cover: fiscal year (96), district (U.S.),
referral agency (all), lead charge (all), program category (civil rights)

Copyright 1998, TRAC Reports, Inc.